Gastroenterology Research, ISSN 1918-2805 print, 1918-2813 online, Open Access
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, Gastroenterol Res and Elmer Press Inc
Journal website https://gr.elmerpub.com

Original Article

Volume 18, Number 5, October 2025, pages 207-223


Risk Stratification and Contemporary Predictors of Survival in Hepatocellular Carcinoma Treated With Transarterial Radioembolization

Figures

Figure 1.
Figure 1. Impact of ICIs on the TARE-related OS in the study population. (a) ICI at any time in their lifetime (697 days) vs. never received ICI (226 days); (b) ICI before TARE (678 days) vs. ICI after TARE (703 days) vs. never received ICI (226 days). ICIs: immune checkpoint inhibitors; OS: overall survival; pre-TARE: ICI before TARE; post-TARE: ICI after TARE; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
Figure 2.
Figure 2. Impact of ICIs on the OS in the study population. (a) ICI at any time in their lifetime (1,102 days) vs. never received ICI (614 days); (b) ICI before TARE (1,959 days) vs. ICI after TARE (927 days) vs. never received ICI (614 days). ICIs: immune checkpoint inhibitors; OS: overall survival; pre-TARE: ICI before TARE; post-TARE: ICI after TARE; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
Figure 3.
Figure 3. Comparing PFS in patients based on the response noted in the first post-TARE imaging scan. Red indicates complete response, green indicates disease progression, blue indicates partial response, and yellow indicates ambiguous response. PFS: progression-free survival; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.

Tables

Table 1. Baseline Characteristics of the Study Population (N = 141)
 
Characteristicn (%)
a24 patients had two-staged TAREs. bBefore first TARE. AFP: alpha-fetoprotein; DM: diabetes mellitus; HCC: hepatocellular carcinoma; HE: hepatic encephalopathy; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; INR: international normalized ratio; MAFLD: metabolic-dysfunction-associated fatty liver disease; PVTT: portal vein tumor thrombus; SBRT: stereotactic body radiotherapy; TACE: transarterial chemoembolization; TARE: transarterial radioembolization; T bili: total bilirubin; TKI: tyrosine kinase inhibitor.
Median age of diagnosis65 years (range 49 - 88)
Race
  White113 (80.14%)
  African American22 (15.60%)
  Other6 (4.26%)
Sex
  Male113 (80.14%)
  Female28 (19.86%)
History of hepatitis B infection8 (5.67%)
History of hepatitis C infection72 (51.06%)
History of alcoholic liver cirrhosis110 (78.01%)
History of MAFLD17 (12.06%)
History of DM50 (35.46%)
Ascites at diagnosis35 (24.82%)
HE at diagnosis41 (29.08%)
Smoking history
  Active52 (37%)
  Former53 (38%)
  Never36 (25%)
Alcohol use
  Active52 (37%)
  Never65 (46%)
  Former24 (17%)
Number of TARE procedures
  1122 (87%)a
  217 (12%)
  32 (1%)
Therapy before TARE
  None50 (35.46%)
  TACE59 (41.84%)
  Ablation35 (24.82%)
  Surgery18 (12.77%)
  SBRT7 (4.97%)
  Systemic therapy12 (8.52%)
Number of HCC lesions
  165 (46.10%)
  230 (21.28%)
  316 (11.35%)
  > 330 (21.28%)
Size of HCC lesions
  ≤ 3 cm56 (40%)
  > 3 cm79 (56%)
  Not measurable6 (4%)
HCC in liver lobes
  Right lobe66 (46.81%)
  Both lobes47 (33.33%)
  Left lobe23 (16.31%)
  Undefined5 (3.55%)
PVTT
  None107 (75.89%)
  Main portal vein14 (9.93%)
  Right portal vein9 (6.38%)
  Present but location is unclear7 (4.97%)
  Left portal vein4 (2.84%)
Child-Pugh score
  A105 (74.47%)
  B34 (24.11%)
  C2 (1.42%)
Baselineb T bili (mg/dL; median/mean)1/1.05
Baselineb albumin (g/dL; median/mean)4/3.76
Baselineb INR (median/mean)1/1.09
Baselineb AFP (ng/dL; median/mean)26.5 (1 - 78,314)/1,688.10
TKI use
  No107 (76%)
  Post-TARE29 (21%)
  Pre-TARE5 (3%)
TKI drugs used
  Sorafenib21 (14.89%)
  Lenvatinib16 (11.35%)
  Cabozantinib2 (1.42%)
ICI use
  No-ICI group102 (72.34%)
  Post-TARE ICI group34 (24.11%)
  Pre-TARE ICI group5 (3.55%)
ICI drugs used
  Nivolumab19 (49%)
  Atezolizumab and bevacizumab20 (51%)

 

Table 2. Factors Impacting PFS in the Study Population Treated With TARE
 
FactorUnivariateMultivariate
HR95% CIP-valueAdjusted HR95% CIP-value
aBaseline: before TARE. *Significant P values. CI: confidence interval; HE: hepatic encephalopathy; HR: hazard ratio; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; MAFLD: metabolic-dysfunction-associated fatty liver disease; PVTT: portal vein tumor thrombus; SBRT: stereotactic body radiotherapy; TACE: transarterial chemoembolization; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
ICI used before TARE
  No------
  Yes0.640.26 - 1.580.30.900.32 - 2.510.8
Age at diagnosis0.990.97 - 1.020.60.990.97 - 1.020.7
Race
  White------
  African American/Black0.860.53 - 1.390.50.940.54 - 1.650.8
  Other0.590.22 - 1.610.30.450.15 - 1.340.2
Hepatitis C
  No------
  Yes0.910.65 - 1.290.60.980.62 - 1.55>0.9
MAFLD
  No------
  Yes1.640.98 - 2.760.0611.560.84 - 2.890.2
SBRT
  No------
  Yes1.050.59 - 1.870.90.970.52 - 1.82> 0.9
TACE
  No------
  Yes1.380.96 - 2.000.0811.400.91 - 2.150.13
Number of lesions
  Single------
  > 11.240.87 - 1.750.21.120.76 - 1.640.6
Size of the lesions
  ≤ 3 cm------
  > 3 cm or not measurable1.200.84 - 1.710.31.220.82 - 1.790.3
Baselinea total bilirubin0.970.75 - 1.250.80.700.50 - 0.970.034*
Baselinea albumin0.630.48 - 0.840.002*0.580.40 - 0.850.005*
Active smoking
  No------
  Yes0.970.68 - 1.390.90.890.59 - 1.330.6
Active alcohol
  No------
  Yes1.150.80 - 1.640.51.280.85 - 1.910.2
Ascites
  No------
  Yes1.541.03 - 2.280.034*1.360.82 - 2.240.2
HE
  No------
  Yes1.461.00 - 2.120.048*1.290.84 - 1.960.2
PVTT - absent vs. present
  Absent------
  Present0.720.47 - 1.090.120.830.51 - 1.350.4
PVTT - specific
  None------
  Left portal vein0.220.05 - 0.920.038*---
  Main portal vein0.870.48 - 1.550.6---
  Present, but the location is unclear1.290.57 - 2.960.5---
  Right portal vein0.660.32 - 1.360.3---

 

Table 3. Factors Impacting TARE-Specific OS in the Study Population
 
FactorUnivariateMultivariate
HR95% CIP-valueAdjusted HR95% CIP-value
aBaseline: before TARE. *Significant P values. CI: confidence interval; HE: hepatic encephalopathy; HR: hazard ratio; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; MAFLD: metabolic-dysfunction-associated fatty liver disease; PVTT: portal vein tumor thrombus; SBRT: stereotactic body radiotherapy; TACE: transarterial chemoembolization; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
ICI use
  No------
  Pre-TARE0.420.15 - 1.160.100.610.17 - 2.180.6
  Post-TARE0.500.32 - 0.780.002*0.370.23 - 0.61< 0.001*
Age at diagnosis1.000.98 - 1.02> 0.91.010.98 - 1.040.6
Race
  White------
  African American/Black0.780.47 - 1.300.30.840.47 - 1.500.6
  Other0.700.26 - 1.920.50.630.20 - 1.960.4
Hepatitis C
  No------
  Yes0.930.65 - 1.340.71.030.64 - 1.670.9
MAFLD
  No------
  Yes1.861.09 - 3.190.023*2.131.10 - 4.130.026*
SBRT
  No------
  Yes0.660.34 - 1.260.20.630.30 - 1.340.2
TACE
  No------
  Yes1.200.82 - 1.750.31.280.78 - 2.110.3
Number of lesions
  Single------
  Multiple1.350.93 - 1.950.111.290.85 - 1.950.2
Size of the lesions
  ≤ 3 cm------
  > 3 cm or not measurable0.980.88 - 1.42> 0.90.960.82 - 1.490.9
Baselinea total bilirubin1.180.92 - 1.520.20.850.61 - 1.180.3
Baselinea albumin0.620.47 - 0.82< 0.001*0.550.38 - 0.800.002*
Active smoking
  No------
  Yes1.190.82 - 1.740.41.050.67 - 1.630.8
Active alcohol
  No------
  Yes1.040.71 - 1.530.81.280.83 - 1.960.3
Ascites
  No------
  Yes1.861.23 - 2.810.003*1.540.89 - 2.660.13
HE
  No------
  Yes2.101.43 - 3.09< 0.001*2.401.49 - 3.88< 0.001*
Surgery
  No------
  Yes0.810.47 - 1.390.41.210.62 - 2.370.6
Ablation
  No------
  Yes1.000.67 - 1.48> 0.90.910.55 - 1.490.7
PVTT - absent vs. present
  Absent------
  Present0.690.44 - 1.070.100.710.41 - 1.250.2
PVTT - specific vein
  None------
  Left portal vein0.210.05 - 0.870.031*---
  Main portal vein1.220.66 - 2.190.5---
  Present, but location is unclear0.530.17 - 1.670.3---
  Right portal Vein0.630.29 - 1.370.2---

 

Table 4. Factors Impacting OS in the Study Population
 
FactorUnivariateMultivariate
HR95% CIP-valueAdjusted HR95% CIP-value
aBaseline: before TARE. *Significant P values. CI: confidence interval; HE: hepatic encephalopathy; HR: hazard ratio; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; MAFLD: metabolic-dysfunction-associated fatty liver disease; OS: overall survival; PVTT: portal vein tumor thrombus; SBRT: stereotactic body radiotherapy; TACE: transarterial chemoembolization; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
ICI use
  No------
  Yes - pre-TARE0.390.14 - 1.070.0670.920.28 - 3.33> 0.9
  Yes - post-TARE0.650.42 - 1.020.0590.670.42 - 1.070.090
Age of diagnosis1.010.99 - 1.040.21.010.98 - 1.040.4
Race
  White------
  African American/Black0.710.43 - 1.180.20.810.44 - 1.480.5
  Other0.540.20 - 1.470.20.510.15 - 1.670.3
Hepatitis C
  No------
  Yes0.680.47 - 0.990.043*0.750.43 - 1.310.3
MAFLD
  No------
  Yes2.231.30 - 3.830.0041.860.92 - 3.730.082*
SBRT
  No------
  Yes0.670.35 - 1.290.20.550.26 - 1.150.11
TACE
  No------
  Yes0.770.53 - 1.130.21.130.70 - 1.810.6
Number of lesions
  Single------
  Multiple1.320.91 - 1.910.141.080.71 - 1.640.7
Size of the lesions
  ≤ 3 cm------
  > 3 cm or multiple1.270.87 - 1.850.21.080.68 - 1.720.7
Baselinea total bilirubin1.170.88 - 1.550.30.900.65 - 1.250.5
Baselinea albumin0.710.54 - 0.940.016*0.630.43 - 0.930.019*
Active smoking
  No------
  Yes0.950.65 - 1.380.81.090.69 - 1.740.7
Active alcohol
  No------
  Yes1.040.71 - 1.520.91.270.83 - 1.950.3
Ascites
  No------
  Yes1.751.16 - 2.640.008*1.710.97 - 3.040.065*
HE
  No------
  Yes1.611.09 - 2.360.016*2.011.22 - 3.320.006*
BMI1.031.00 - 1.060.0671.010.97 - 1.050.7
Line of TARE used
  First------
  > 10.700.48 - 1.030.0690.730.41 - 1.300.3
Surgery
  No------
  Yes0.560.32 - 0.970.038*0.830.42 - 1.650.6
Ablation
  No------
  Yes0.500.33 - 0.75< 0.001*0.350.21 - 0.59< 0.001*
PVTT
  None------
  Present1.060.70 - 1.690.70.720.39 - 1.350.3

 

Table 5. Impact of TARE on Liver Function
 
Mean differenceLowerUpperP-value
TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
Albumin0.530.420.63< 0.0001
Total bilirubin-0.91-1.29-0.53< 0.0001
Child-Pugh score-1.36-1.63-1.09< 0.0001

 

Table 6. Factors Influencing Survival in HCC Patients Treated With TARE in Our Study
 
PFSOS-TAREOS
aHas a trend toward significance with a P-value of 0.05 to 0.08. HE: hepatic encephalopathy; ICI: immune checkpoint inhibitor; MAFLD: metabolic-dysfunction-associated fatty liver disease; OS: overall survival; OS-TARE: TARE-specific OS; PFS: progression-free survival; PVTT: portal vein tumor thrombus; TARE: transarterial radioembolization.
Multivariate analysis
  Better survivalHigh albuminHigh albumin
Post-TARE ICI
High albumin
Prior ablation
  Poor survivalLow total bilirubinHE
MAFLD
HE
MAFLDa
Ascitesa
Univariate analysis
  Better survivalHigh albumin
Left vein PVTT
Post-TARE ICI
High albumin
No PVTT
Albumin
Prior surgery or ablation Hepatitis C
  Poor survivalMAFLDa
HE
MAFLD
HE
Ascites
HE